(Featured Image: “Untitled (Make-Up),” Richard Prince, 1983.)

Even after recruiting Denise Matthews to be the group’s frontwoman, Prince still envisioned Vanity 6 as a girl group in the classic sense, with each member taking the lead on their respective songs. This gave him the opportunity to return to a pair of tracks originally recorded for the Hookers project in the summer of 1981, featuring Susan Moonsie on lead vocals. Though they date back to almost a year earlier than the rest of the album, “Make-Up” and “Drive Me Wild” sound cutting-edge. Like “All the Critics Love U in New York,” both songs seem to parallel the emerging sounds of Detroit techno–particularly “Make-Up,” with Susan’s deliberately cold, dispassionate vocals, a frenetic Linn LM-1 pattern, and a synth-bass line that resembles a computer processor clearing its throat.

“Sharevari” on Detroit music show The Scene in February 1982; note the Controversy-era Prince impersonator at 0:47.

It is, of course, tricky to establish what Prince might have heard before he recorded “Make-Up”–particularly since the song’s exact recording date remains unknown. But the track bears more than a passing structural resemblance to “Sharevari,” a proto-techno single released by Detroit group A Number of Names in 1981. The two songs share a percolating electronic pulse, a faux-European air of detached sophistication, and a chorus that repeats the title to a simple call-and-response rhythm: “Share / Vari”; “Make / Up.” Both also include keyboard lines with an exotic, vaguely Middle Eastern feel. It’s possible, however, that Prince and the producers behind A Number of Names were simply working from the same pool of shared influences: “Sharevari”’s stylistic elements can themselves be traced back to tracks like 1979’s “Moskow Diskow” by the Belgian electronic group Telex–or even further, to 1978’s “The Robots” by Kraftwerk.

Lyrically, “Make-Up” matches its arrangement’s ice-cold glamour with a portrait of Moonsie as a fembot at her toilette. My fellow song-by-song Prince blog 500 Prince Songs describes the song as a “YouTube make-up tutorial given by the Kraftwerk shop dummies”; Susan blankly recites the step-by-step of her routine, her voice barely even registering annoyance when an off-camera, presumably male partner interrupts her: “Hush / See what you made me do?” The only real emotion she shows is when she frets to herself over what to wear on her date, before eventually settling on the Vanity 6 uniform of choice: “If I wear a dress / He will never call / So I’ll wear much less / I guess I’ll wear my camisole.” The image of Susan as a docile, Stepford Wife-like figure programmed for male visual pleasure is unsettling, but mitigated somewhat by the fact that Prince has been on her side of the make-up brush: when she tells her boyfriend, “Smoke a cigarette / I’m not ready yet,” it feels less like a sexist joke about women taking forever to get ready and more like Prince commiserating over just how much time it takes to get one’s eyeliner right.

Drag queen Raven performs to Amanda Blank’s version of “Make-Up” at Micky’s in West Hollywood; shot by Myles Matisse.

At just over two and a half minutes long, “Make-Up” scans as an appealing throwaway on the Vanity 6 album; but as 500 Prince Songs observes, its influence extends beyond its lowly origins to become “an icy crucible of dance music worlds.” Notably, an electroclash-flavored version by Philadelphia-based rapper Amanda Blank was released in 2009. If anything, it sounds more dated than the Vanity 6 original; great “Make-Up” is timeless.

“Make-Up” (Vanity 6, 1982) YouTube
“Make-Up” (Amanda Blank, 2009) Spotify

4 thoughts on “Make-Up

  1. Yow! I just got “Originals” this weekend and now totally understand the love I’ve seen for “Make Up.” I just played it this morning driving to work and I can’t wait to hear it play again. I’ll get back with further thoughts after I’ve given it a few more spins and get a handle on what it may or may not remind me of. But it’s definitely Prince in coldwave drag! Maybe it’s time to get over my reticence of feeling pandered to and give “Vanity 6” a listen?

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, I love it and would love to hear Prince’s versions of “Drive Me Wild” and other Vanity 6 tracks; it would be a great way to free the songs from the weird, exploitative undertones we’ve talked about before!

      Liked by 1 person

      1. And how. It might free up the songs from their cheap, sub-adolescent origins. I can dig the sound but I don’t wanna feel cheap. There we are. “[I Don’t Wanna Feel] Cheap;” The Vanity 6 song title that might have been a game changer!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s